Missed Casting – “China Seas” (1935)

27 May

china seas

“China Seas” was the original “Die Hard”, a true classic adventure film from the Golden Age of movies. Adapted from a 300 page novel by Crosbie Garstin, it’s a story of modern day Pirates that attack a cruise ship in search of a hidden treasure being guarded by the tough as nails English Captain Alan Gaskell, wonderfully played by Clark Gable.

…Wait, what? The all-American Clark Gable as an English ship Captain?(Oh, I know, he played Fletcher Christian but STILL…) Don’t misunderstand me, “China Seas” is one of my favorite Clark Gable films. An all-star cast that sees him at his peak while playing opposite the likes of Jean Harlow, Wallace Beery, Rosalind Russell, C. Aubrey Smith and Hattie McDaniel. It’s just that this adventure film easily could have been (Nay, SHOULD have been!) a movie that starred Errol Flynn. Imagine Errol Flynn as a modern-day hard drinking, womanizing, heroic Captain of a ship who romances two leading ladies while also fighting Pirates with a machine gun and you start to see my point.

It’s a wonderfully entertaining film and incredibly influential if you factor in the numerous parallels with the later “Die Hard” blockbuster. (Like Bruce Willis, Gable’s Captain Alan Gaskell has to fight Pirates while also dealing with a horrific foot injury.) But it also highlights the fact that Clark Gable and Errol Flynn often seemed to play roles that could have been written for one another.(Robin Hood being a notable exception.) And certainly, Errol was part of the Rhett Butler casting triangle that pitted him against Gary Cooper and Clark Gable for the lead role in “Gone With The Wind”, a part Flynn had campaigned for and Gable had shunned. The truth is Rhett Butler was Gable’s best-suited role as much as Robin Hood had been Flynn’s.

But despite Gable’s masterful movie star turn as Captain Alan Gaskell, there’s no escaping that the role was clearly written for an Englishman, with numerous references that scream for an English accent to back up the character’s yearning to return there. Throw in a modern day pirate story and it all adds up to Clark Gable playing the Errol Flynn role. This is a role that Flynn might have elevated if Warner’s had purchased the book instead of MGM. Of course, Gable and Jean Harlow were a tremendous screen team and this is one of their best. But Errol Flynn as the cultured Englishman being pursued and fought over by the equally cultured Rosalind Russell and the crass but feisty Jean Harlow? To paraphrase Humphrey Bogart, that’s the stuff that movie dreams are made of.


— zacal


Posted in Main Page


Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  1. Gentleman Tim

    May 27, 2015 at 9:36 pm

    Excellent write-up, zacal. Thanks. Never thought about it previously, but your undoubtedly right about Errol being a terrific candidate for both this and Die Hard. After all, wasn’t Alan Rickman channeling Sir Guy of Rathbone in DH-1? And wouldn’t Samuel L. Jackson have been perfect with Flynn?

    Btw, Gable looks more nervous about that guy with the earing and red lipstick than about those fearsome South Seas pirates.


  2. zacal

    May 27, 2015 at 11:50 pm

    Wow, what a terrific set photo.

  3. rswilltell

    May 28, 2015 at 5:46 pm

    I agree with Tim, Zacal did an excellent article on ‘China Seas’. As long as Clark Gable played a swaggering, macho sea captain who loved and dumped the ladies, MGM had a big hit on their hands. When Gable played the idealistic and humble Irish patriot in ‘Parnell’ (1937) for MGM with Myrna Loy, it laid an egg at the box office. ‘Parnell’ was laughed out of the theatres but if you see it on TCM, you’ll be surprised at how good both Gable and the film are. In those days and even still today, movie stars played against their type at their own peril. By the way Gable was British again with Rosalind Russell in the adventure film ‘The Met In Bombay’ (1941). Yes he was a swaggering macho con-man. Gable actually does some genuine exciting swashbuckling like Flynn as a British Army Captain single-handily defeating a battalion of Japanese! Ralph Schiller

  4. shangheinz

    May 28, 2015 at 8:27 pm

    Great posts, stills and in debt comments like these make a great blog. Thanks fellow Flynn fans.